Phone: (314) 843-0102
Fax: (314) 843-0508
flag image

Crestwood aldermen weigh RFP for planning consultant

Redevelopment of mall topic at Ward 1 town-hall meeting

Mike Anthony
Executive Editor
September 25, 2013 - A draft request for proposals for a planning services consultant to assist Crestwood officials in "navigating" the process for the proposed redevelopment of Crestwood Court was set to be discussed earlier this week by the Board of Aldermen.

The Board of Aldermen was scheduled to meet Tuesday night — after the Call went to press.

Aldermen voted 5-3 earlier this month to have City Administrator Mark Sime draft the revised request for proposals, or RFP, for a planning consultant to assist city officials in evaluating Centrum Properties' proposal to redevelop Crestwood Court.

Centrum, the mall's owner along with Angelo, Gordon & Co., has proposed an open-air entertainment and retail complex with restaurants, a movie theater, an upscale bowling venue and retail shops.

As proposed, Centrum's total redevelopment cost is roughly $121 million, with economic assistance in the form of tax-increment financing, or TIF, a transportation development district, or TDD, and a community improvement district, or CID, reaching roughly $34 million.

In a Sept. 18 memo to Mayor Jeff Schlink and the Board of Aldermen, Sime wrote, "As I understand from previous discussions, you want the consultant to focus on a review and assessment of the developer's current proposal and its ability to meet the needs of the city both as a regional draw and for revenue production. I wrote the RFP to ask the consultant to do more than that.

"A planner should do market, demographic, existing conditions and public-support analysis to help the city design criteria for the proposal which will help the city meet our vision and business objectives for the city ..."

Sime also wrote, "To help any consultant meet these needs, we should be able to provide the following to the consultant:

• "What is Crestwood's brand now?

• "What/where does Crestwood want to be in five, 10, 20 years?

• "Will the proposed plan support the future of Crestwood, not just from a commerce/revenue standpoint, but, most important, will it support the lifestyle and a healthy well-being of a small Midwestern city?"

In September 2012, aldermen voted to select Peckham Guyton Albers & Viets, or PGAV, as the city's planning consultant for the mall redevelopment. PGAV completed a preliminary analysis of the mall property, but withdrew its proposal in July after an ordinance approving a more comprehensive study was rejected for a third time by the board.

Besides voting Sept. 10 to have Sime draft the RFP, the board voted 6-2 to rescind the second paragraph of Resolution 12-03, which had given city officials authority to move forward with convening a TIF Commission for the proposed redevelopment of the mall. Ward 2 Alderman Mary Stadter and Ward 4 Alderman Dan Tennessen opposed removing the paragraph.

The draft RFP and the removal of the paragraph from the resolution were discussed last week during a town-hall meeting sponsored by Ward 1 Aldermen Richard Breeding and Darryl Wallach.

The Sept. 17 meeting at the Government Center attracted less than a dozen residents, including former Ward 1 Aldermen Mimi Duncan and Gregg Roby and former Ward 4 Alderman Steve Nieder. Also attending were Sime and Mayor Jeff Schlink.

Breeding said he believes the board is "moving in the right direction" regarding the mall.

"... It is baby steps, but at least we're moving in the right direction and you don't have the 4-4 split on the board. It's now 5-3, and that could change, but it's a good move in the right direction ..."

Breeding asked if residents had any questions about the redevelopment of the mall, and Nieder said, "Since the proposal (for the mall) has not fundamentally changed and was rejected multiple times by the board, why are we continuing to even invest money in a planner?"

Breeding replied, "... This is my opinion. Hopefully, the money we're investing is not ours. It comes out ... reimbursed via the TIF, eventually. But the reason I believe that — I can't speak for the whole board — but the reason I voted to go forward with this is it does change because we've asked for residential. We've also hinted at what can we do with the Crestwood Industrial Park, too. So I think the scope has changed a little bit."

Nieder said, "That was your request. That was not agreed to by the developer. In fact, it was rejected multiple times."

Breeding said, "Right."

Nieder continued, "So fundamentally, the proposal still has not changed."

Breeding said, "I think it's changed a little."

Breeding and Nieder continued to exchange comments about the project, and Breeding finally said, "... On the PGAV assessment that came out, (PGAV Vice President) John Brancaglione warned against debating or negotiating in public.

"And that's one thing I thought all along that without a developer on our side — or either side — and just negotiating in public and someone hears one thing one way and someone construes it the other way, we don't have a common ground. So that's my opinion."

Wallach said he considered the board's vote to have Sime draft the RFP as progress.

Of the mall site, he said, "... We both feel this is a viable area — I think the board does. Again, I think the disconnect we have is the type of development that goes in there ..."

Tags: Crestwood News

  • Related Editorial
    Impact News
    Local meeting guide 2017
    Jan 08 2014
    All meeting times, dates and locations are subject to change for 2017. ...
    Impact News
    Total Eclipse 2017: No shortage of events for total eclipse
    ‘Excitement is building’ for first total eclipse in St. Louis since 1442, Stenger says
    Aug 16 2017
    As the path of totality of the Great American Solar Eclipse crosses directly through south county next week, schools, residents and government agencies are gearing up for what could be a once-in-a-lifetime ...
    Impact News
    Lindbergh community celebrates opening of Dressel Elementary
    School will be a ‘relief valve’ to ease district overcrowding
    Aug 09 2017
    A ribbon-cutting ceremony last week marking the grand opening of Lindbergh Schools’ state-of-the-art new Dressel Elementary School was “a historic day,” according to Superintendent Jim Simpson....
    Transparency continuing to take a hit under Stump
    'Call the Tune' by Mike Anthiony: Crestwood becomes opaque with city attorney’s guidance
    Aug 09 2017
    Simple math apparently is a topic protected by attorney-client privilege in Crestwood....
    Crestwood to offer 13th annual Kids’ Triathlon
    Aug 09 2017
    The Crestwood Parks and Recreation Department will sponsor its 13th annual Kids’ Triathlon at 8 a.m. Sunday, Aug. 26, at the Aquatic Center at Whitecliff Park, 9245 Whitecliff Park Lane....
Site Search

Type in your zip code and click "Go" to get your 7-day forecast.